Accession Number : ADA483510


Title :   Use of Information Technology Tools in Source Selection Decision Making: A Study on USAF's KC-X Tanker Replacement Program


Descriptive Note : MBA professional rept.


Corporate Author : NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL MONTEREY CA


Personal Author(s) : Kaymaz, Sidar ; Diri, Alaattin


Full Text : https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a483510.pdf


Report Date : Jun 2008


Pagination or Media Count : 171


Abstract : The source selection phase in government acquisitions is so complicated in nature because it involves multi-criteria decision making that is supposed to respond to various requirements and subjectivity is usually inevitable in this kind of a decision making process. The purpose of this project is to demonstrate how the USAF's current source selection method (color rating method) is incompetent in showing small differences between proposed products, how this inadequacy leads to subjective decisions, and that the use of information technology tools can augment objectivity in this process. In this study, USAF's KC-X Tanker Replacement Program has been selected as the program to be used to frame the research questions. Two models with two versions built on Microsoft Excel spreadsheets using publicly available KC-X program data are used to compare the USAF's color rating method and weighted sum method, which is a multi-criteria decision making tool. It is presented that if the USAF had used the weighted sum method as its evaluation method, the winner of the KC-X program could have been different. The findings prove that the color rating method is not capable of reflecting small differences and information technology tools can help decision makers choose the best value offeror with less subjectivity.


Descriptors :   *DECISION MAKING , *TANKER AIRCRAFT , SOFTWARE TOOLS , RATINGS , SELECTION , CONTRACT PROPOSALS , REFUELING IN FLIGHT , INFORMATION SYSTEMS , ACQUISITION , REPLACEMENT


Subject Categories : Transport Aircraft
      Administration and Management


Distribution Statement : APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE