Accession Number : ADA482245


Title :   Are Marines a Better Fit for Afghanistan


Descriptive Note : Research rept.


Corporate Author : ARMY WAR COLL CARLISLE BARRACKS PA


Personal Author(s) : Tart, William M


Full Text : https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a482245.pdf


Report Date : Mar 2008


Pagination or Media Count : 35


Abstract : In October 2007, the Commandant of the Marine Corps General James Conway proposed to the new Secretary of Defense and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs that his Marines take a larger role in the counterinsurgency fight in Afghanistan. This plan, leaked to the New York Times, immediately drew criticism from those who characterized the plan as a power grab, Within weeks, retired general officers generals who spoke on condition of anonymity, and others who viewed the proposal through the lens of perceived service equities generated a list of reasons why the plan should be rejected. This clouded the issue for Defense Department decision makers. Instead had these same pundits closely examined the mission and the requirements, applied the feasibility, acceptability, and suitability (FAS) test, and eliminated arguments which were based on service parochialism, the U.S. may have saved months in implementing this simple plan to achieve our Nation's goals This paper briefly details the history of the issue. spells out the proposal. and applies the FAS check. The aim of this paper is to illustrate how quickly the simplest thing becomes difficult and present a methodology to apply to future decision making where service interests cloud the issue.


Descriptors :   *AFGHANISTAN , *DECISION MAKING , *COUNTERINSURGENCY , MARINE CORPS , GENERAL OFFICERS , RETIREMENT(PERSONNEL) , ACCEPTABILITY , DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE , METHODOLOGY , MILITARY FORCES(UNITED STATES) , MARINE CORPS PERSONNEL


Subject Categories : Administration and Management
      Personnel Management and Labor Relations
      Unconventional Warfare


Distribution Statement : APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE